"The entire group felt like one unit and the trial. I believe ends that," Kevin Alves tells PEOPLE, adding, "The entire group felt like one unit and the trial. I believe ends that unit for good"

If any two characters were the most affected by the trial of Coach Ben, it was Sophie Thatcher’s Natalie and Samantha Hanratty’s Misty. Natalie built a close bond with Coach Ben while in the wilderness,